This Is American Soccer, US Soccer, MNT, WNT, and MLS - Tackling the subject of Soccer in the US, and worldwide.

85 players over 59 matches. A record of 36-9-14. Now it’s down to 23 and 0-0-0. I’ve been thinking about this day for three years. This is the beginning of the end, and with every end, there spawns a new beginning. Let the games and the debates begin. The finals are upon us - a few cream puff games between now and then are not going to deride me from making such a comment. Nor is the fact that an injury here or there could make this entire diatribe completely meaningless. It’s open season, and I’m not talking about the fact that the MLS just started.

Yeah, yeah, yeah - Twellman and Berhalter didn’t make the cut. My inbox has been filling up since about 6:10pm last night. Let’s just get it out of the way: neither deserve to go to Germany, even if an injury comes up there are better options than either man. I like Kerry Zavagnin and Chris Albright (yes, I know Kerry is not a forward).

Those with good memories will recall I questioned Twellman’s place a while back. While there are flashes of greatness in the MLS golden booter, too often the little guy disappears on the field. Best described as strict goal scorer at this point in his career, the opportunistic Twellman doesn’t bring enough to the part of the field that lies outside the penalty box. While the numbers don’t lie (lots of goals), they certainly don’t tell the whole story. The all-star athlete with immense potential just needs some fine tuning to befit a finals appearance, which will surely come his way in 2010.

One would think you could say the same thing for Berhalter for 2006. After all, he was on the 2002 squad and started two games. But that was before the Germany game, not in the quarter finals, but last month. That 4-1 loss must now hang heavily on his mind, if it didn’t already. There is no way around it. He played poorly, mental breakdowns after physical lapses, and never (before or after) showed he was one of the best options on a back line that will ultimately take us as far as we go. That loss to Germany wasn’t his fault, but his fate was eulogized that evening. Arena can say what he wants about not basing his decisions on a single match, but that isn’t anything but Bruce saying what he is supposed to say.

ching.jpeg
boot straps

Ching and Conrad took their places, just as Twellman and/or Berhalter might still take a spot for an injured player – Obrien, McBride, Reyna, Johnson (can we get a few more physical question marks?). Conrad has a good head on his shoulders and has yet to make any mistakes, which can mean the difference of a first round departure and quarter finals appearance. Ching has been red hot in the early MLS season and brings size and control to the front line, though he isn’t exactly the goal scoring threat the US desperately needs. It is also worth noting that no matter which of these four names gets turned into FIFA on May 15th, the day the rosters are due, actual playing time may not even be their’s. This is essentially an argument over the strength of our bench.

Before our planes land in Germany on June 1 (with the Czech Republic on June 12, Italy on June 17, and Ghana on June 22), we will face Morocco in Nashville on May 23, Venezuela in Cleveland on May 26, and Latvia in Hartford on May 28. It will be nice to see a full side. And it will give our MLS players more chances to get into shape… don’t get me started - just another example of the American-centricity with the increasing idiocy of MLS brass as it relates to the soccer universe. (sorry, I had to get that in there).

Amendment; May 3

Chris Albright replaces Frankie Hejduk (torn knee ligament) on the 23 man roster.

Patrick
on May 3rd, 2006 - 2:59pm

Well I agree with everything but the fitness comment. While Arena has said some things about this year I remember last world cup may European teams complaining the reason they bowed out early was because their seasons were too long and too close to the World Cup. I would rather have to work players hard for a month before and have fresh legs then injuries or dead legs at the end of seasons…

Stephen Ramone
on May 3rd, 2006 - 3:55pm

spot on Adam! MLS needs to get in line with world-wide scheduling. i agree with the tiredness argument of Patrick, i’d rather have them tired than coming off a long off-season. A lesser of two evils. Maybe mid-season World Cups would be the way to go?

either way - the point i wanted to make was I don’t like Twellman and am glad he didnt make it. Nothing personal, I just don’t think he is much more than a cherry picker. when was the last time we saw him do anything but get cheap goals? he gets by on his natural ability, not on soccer skill perse’

Connor
on May 3rd, 2006 - 4:12pm

Jimmy Conrad was a huge surprise to me, I thought he played worse than Berhalter in the Germany game and if he gets in just because of the form he has had in the MLS, shouldn’t that warrent Twellman a spot as well? I was a bit confused by the remarks Arena made during his Sports Center interview. We really lack a scoring option off the bench, in ‘02 i thought Mathis was kind of our late game super sub guy but in ‘06 there clearly is not one of those players. Josh Wolff and Brian Ching? I’m not sure the mention of either of those two guys are causing any headaches among our group opponents.

Steve
on May 3rd, 2006 - 5:40pm

Albright is worthless, I don’t understand how he’s the only one Arena can find to fill that spot, there must be at least 20 American players capable of playing that position. I’ll admit his work rate in the last few months has increased (no doubt due to the watching eye of Arena and the final list), but he’s a second rate player by our standards.

I’m also glad this will be Reyna’s last Cup. I’m sorry but I just don’t think he’s been playing at the level that made him famous 8 years ago, he’s old, tired and has lost almost all the vision he had. It’s time to let O’brian and others step up. Arena didn’t give enough of the other options a chance in the friendly’s to show what they can do, and I think Reyna is going to be a large dissapointment in Germany.

I like the rest of his list though. If not for the target on our backs this time around I think we have a fighting chance.

Chris Totushek
on May 3rd, 2006 - 5:47pm

The sagacity of Arena’s selections for the 23 man team this cup will ultimately be decided on injury and fitness. And while that might be as revealing as saying the outcome of the matches will depend heavily on the number of goals we score, our success will be determined by how well our team links up on the field. Reyna and O’Brien have the temperment to settle the midfield and develop play from the back, but neither is quite back to full fitness. I think Ching was included with Johnson to add as many foils to McBride’s playing style as we may need. While I am not convinced of Ching’s skills, his physical presence may be enough to ruffle some teams back lines. Twellman is just too similar to a very young McBride: both are poaching attackers needing service. The question centers on the adaptability of the team’s playing style. If Renya gets injured, can move our game out to the wings more? If McBride goes down, can the team adapt to let Johnson and Dempsey run at defenders?

Kyle
on May 3rd, 2006 - 7:40pm

I’m not too upset to see Hejduk go, and I think Albright is a good replacement. Hejduk was good for a time but the last game convinced me he didn’t deserve it. Ching is a mystery. Aside from being in the USL 2 years ago, he makes very poor decisions on the field and lacks the skill to be an effective forward. Twellman, I think, deserves the spot. 1) he can capitalize. 2) he gets back on defense. 3) he’s entering his prime. For the record, Reyna is the best field player on the team.

flaherty
on May 3rd, 2006 - 8:24pm

while everyone is looking at this individual and that one, it seems only arena is looking at the team package. sure, just like everyone else, i’m baffled by some of the roster; however, i’ll stand behind our usmnt manager and hope for the best.

Jameson
on May 4th, 2006 - 5:09am

I think we should also mention how much a tactical genius Bruce Arena is. No doubt he was thinking ahead to what style of play he will utilize against the Czechs and Italians. I am sure he picked players like Ching and Conrad over the other deserving players for a reason. I’m excited to see the team prove itself once again to the rest of the world.

Stephen Ramone
on May 4th, 2006 - 8:40am

look at all the Bruce love going around. I think he is overrated, and I would love to see the US MNT when they have a real futball manager. Arnea is a great trainer, great preparer, but i don’t believe he is the best out there.

James
on May 4th, 2006 - 8:47am

Jimmy Conrad is the only really surprising choice to me. And it’s the ultimate “team” choice over “talent” choice.

Bruce isn’t afraid to take a guy that might be a little less talented if he’s a really strong “team guy”. Kind of like Meola in 2002.

Conrad is the ultimate teammate and he’s been a solid player in MLS. So, I shouldn’t be too surprised.

Ultimately, the “bubble boys” of Albright, Conrad, and Ching won’t determine how far this team goes.

How healthy Reyna and O’Brien are will be huge.

Can players like Donovan and Beasley improve over their break out 2002 World Cup performances?

Who will be the break out rookies this time around? You know everyone’s favorite choice in that role will be guys like Gooch, Dempsey, and Johnson. But, will there be a sleeper that really steps up and makes a difference?

In the end, it all gets back to “In Bruce We Trust”. Until he gives me a reason to question his sanity, I’m drinking the Arena Football Kool Aid.

drew
on May 4th, 2006 - 10:04am

I’m sure Bruce chose Ching for his “chemistry with Donovan”, but if that is the case why not just bring Herculez Gomez?

Both Ching and Gomez are where they are today because of Donovan.

I’m sure Twellman with a good cast of characters behind him, rather than the ragtag mf’s he has played with on NT duty, would perform just fine. He would be the best backup to Brian McBride.

flaherty
on May 4th, 2006 - 10:43am

great points, james.
as for “all the bruce love” from stephens comment… i’m jut saying that there’s a very good reason bruce arena is managing this team and not any of us yahoo’s on this or any other board. people should maybe think a bit more about that and respect it.

Stephen Ramone
on May 4th, 2006 - 11:06am

“a very good reason” ??? care to explain this?

christian
on May 4th, 2006 - 11:08am

i 100% agreed with Bruce, he made some tough choics, and some harsh ones, but decisions he and only he could make, ching over twellman Tough but neccesary

flaherty
on May 4th, 2006 - 1:07pm

i hate this internet bickering, but what i’m saying is i’m a graphic designer for a living, and my coaching career hasn’t gotten past my kids recreational U6 team so far. i don’t know what you do for a living stephen, so i’m not going to assume, but i’d be willing to bet the majority of the people posting about bruce arena’s picks for his world cup roster don’t have too much professional coahing experience. i’ve never said he was the best, but i’d say he hasn’t done too bad so far.

Stephen Ramone
on May 4th, 2006 - 1:43pm

“i hate this internet bickering, but…”

get over yourself flaherty. who starts a sentence like that and can take any position they make seriously? the whole point of this comments board, as well as the multi-billion dollar industry that is Sports media revolves around this so-called bickering.

having an opinion on something doesn’t require one to be qualified, in this case, to do the job they are criticizing. You just have to be educated, and even that is a subjective call. Calling Bruce a mediocre coach, taking his team to play Germany without a full squad (for an example of one blunder), doesn’t mean that I can do better. What it means is that someone can.

Jose Mourinho says Chelsea is the worst job because when you win the players and the money spent get all the respect. How about he comes over here and works his oompa loompa magic on the US MNT. he could do better than Arena, and that list is long.

Jameson
on May 4th, 2006 - 4:51pm

Didn’t Arena win collegiate national championships while managing the University of Virginia and win MLS championships with DC United? He’s proven to be the best “American” manager out there. He may not be the best manager in the world, but he is the best in this country and as a growing soccer nation I believe it is important that Arena leads the team because he is an American. That being said, I sincerely hope that after the WC this summer he quits and gets a job coaching a club team in Europe just to prove his skills.

flaherty
on May 4th, 2006 - 8:08pm

totally agree here. something like 5 ncaa championships with UVA and 2 mls championships with dc. only makes sense to have an american manager for the american team. look at all the b.s. going on in england over the same issue. as for jose mourinho, he may ba an amazing manager, but his sportsmanship leaves something to be desired.

James
on May 5th, 2006 - 9:45am

I don’t want to see Bruce move to a European Club.

I want him to be the US Manager for life!!!!!!!!

chad
on May 5th, 2006 - 1:09pm

Arena apologized for scheduling the German game immediately after, and hinted at his under-manned side before the game. I personally felt that the drubbing was a needed reality-check in order to put perspective on our previous performances against Canada, Norway, and Japan

Connor
on May 5th, 2006 - 3:59pm

What are you saying Stephen that Jose should come on over and assume the role of US manager? Thats completley idiotic for a million reasons. Bruce Arena is the most qualified man for the position and the best for it. End of question you need to only look at his credentials to see that. There is no better American coach for the position and no better foreign coach, atleast that would be willing to take the position of course.

hokiefan
on May 6th, 2006 - 6:26pm

i’d rather see twellman come off the bench than wolff. josh must be a heck of a teammate, b/c he sure isn’t doing much on the field these days.

Dan
on May 8th, 2006 - 11:52pm

Without sounding xenophobic… the U.S. nat’l team should be managed by an American. I agree with Connor, et al in this regard. With all of the talk of growing talent at home through MLS and onto the WC squad we also need an American manager with his ear to the ground and intimate knowledge of our game. We had foreigners come over and try their shtick (remember Bora, 1994?) and it was less that impressive. Although there was Sampson as a knock against American coaches. Never-the-less, just when America is developing our American style of play is it crucial that we had American coaches at the fore front of our nat’l team. It wouldn’t send the right message otherwise.

charley_b
on May 9th, 2006 - 10:10pm

I just wanted to chime in that Steve Sampson was a total black mark on American coaching. The guy did such a hack job…

Arena is a great manager for us. I’ve seen him train the team and he’s about letting the players play, taking their backs when he needs to, and managing the psyche of the team.

Look at the player’s he produced out of Virginia during his reign - between Reyna and Olsen he turned out two of the most exciting and classy midfielders during periods when college soccer was a total mess. Those two were great examples for us younger guys coming up…which is likely why Olsen made the squad.

Sean
on May 10th, 2006 - 1:08pm

Let’s put down the red kool aid for a moment folks. I think we all like what Bruce has turned our national team into the past few years, a real threat to play with anyone in the world. I also think most of us aren’t naive enough to believe he isn’t mistake free. We all probably remember Agoos nightmarishly bad play in the last World Cup for one thing. Be happy that he has built a team good enough for us to believe we can take on the Italy’s and Czech’s of the world.

And what fun would the internet be without bickering? That’s what makes sport so great. The passion it incites in fans. It’s why the first thing I do when I get home from working on a computer all day is grab another computer and start checking soccer sites. It’s what inspires us to take risks and love and to hate and all that good stuff. If you think you have to be some sort of expert to post on a blog or a forum thats fine. I for one will be comfortable in my idiocy. I will spend hours at a bar debating the finer points of whats wrong with the mls (lots for short). I feel comfortable sending a 2 page email to a friend in Germany about why I still think we are a better team than them despite our recent drubbing.

I’ve kind of rambled in that last paragraph. But who cares thats my right as an internet sports fan. This is my call to all soccer fans: Stop holding your opinions to yourself. Stop caring about what other people will think about your crazy belief that convey should start at the outside left spot. Let our your inner idiot. Join us.

Brandon
on May 12th, 2006 - 10:27am

Twellman is sick… theres no doubt that he is better than brian ching in at least 5 different ways. Ching is good but i mean who can do more for your national team. Yeah twellman is a pocher but thats what USA needs against tough teams

Fernando
on May 12th, 2006 - 1:19pm

I would have to disagree with Albright be worthless. As a Galaxy fan, i have always been impressed with his work ethic. I think that Lando nis a bit over rated, he never shows up on the big games. His inability to make it over seas was a clear indacation that he is not the greatest footballer ever produced in the USA. I would have to give that to soemoen else; i would even dare to say John Harkes might fit that bill. I dont know what awaits us i Germany, but there are some players on that list that worry me. Reyna is one for sure, he has lost more than a step, he is never match fit and often injured. Well, thats my take so far, just glad to see another four years have past, and ready to see the worlds greatest sport.

leave a comment items marked with * are required

Recent Comments

  • Donj: Question for the two guys from Atlanta lamenting the fact that there is no MLS team in their city to go see: do...
  • mikheil topuria: i am a footballer, i am 20, i played in many geogrian teams. i am a forvard and i am a bombardir. i...
  • Jim: Miami will have MLS soon.
  • Andrew: Soccer has a relatively good base, but that base has two major problems. 1. All kinds of kids play soccer,...
  • Timoteo: I believe the success of a sport is directly related to the number of youths in a country who play the game...