This Is American Soccer, US Soccer, MNT, WNT, and MLS - Tackling the subject of Soccer in the US, and worldwide.

killing me softly

The Fugees. photo credit: Nicole Bengiveno/The New York Times

Dwindling readerships be damned. It still amazes me the power of the newspaper, and more specifically, the front page. Editors wield their power, choosing what to put on the front page, driving what we read thanks to the fact that few of us are going to read an entire newspaper, especially one with the girth of the Sunday New York Times.

It should be no real surprise where I am going with this. Sunday morning found soccer front and center. I got seven e-mails alerting me to Warren St. John’s story by noon yesterday. Would I get those e-mails if the story was buried in the sports section? Would anyone read the story if it wasn’t on the front page? I’d argue the answer to both of those questions is no, although maybe one e-mail might still have arrived – John from Soccer-Training.com beat the others to my in-box by several hours.

These were my thoughts looking at the large spread. Then I read the story.

For those in the know, it is anything but a surprising tale - you know the one about the immigrants finding solidarity from soccer – but it is a story that never gets old. The New York Times should know. Long before I spent a season with Manhattan’s Martin Luther King Jr. High School, the Times followed the city’s sports dynasty for years. Supplant the Clarkston, GA, refugees, or Fugees as the team is called, in Sunday’s story with inner-city ELA (English as Second Language) students, and the racist Clarkston residents for pompous public school politicians, and you essentially have the same story.

That’s not to say every story is not it’s own. Besides the stark contrast in coaches – MLK’s Martin Jacobson (Coach Jake) v. Ms. Mufleh (Coach Luma) – what struck me most was the geography. See, Clarkston, GA, is about an hour from where I grew up in Atlanta, and I witnessed scenarios not too unlike the one unfolding in Clarkston. I remember standing on the sidelines as parents complained about immigrants ‘without papers’ taking the places of their children on the field. Back then – circa mid-1980’s – it was more about ‘I paid so my kid plays’. Now, as evidenced by the Clarkston article, some clubs are paying to bring in talented immigrants. Funny coincidence: the club described in the article as “perhaps Atlanta’s most elite — and expensive — soccer academy,” is the one I played for. Although now called Concorde Fire, after two clubs Concorde (mine) and the Atlanta Fire joined forces, it seems little has changed – the well-to-do white kids from suburbs north of Atlanta, the weekend pool parties, the summer soccer camps, the spending in excess of $5,000 per player - except one thing:

“There is one other expenditure. The parents of the Fire collectively finance the play of Jorge Pinzon, a Colombian immigrant and the son of a single working mother. He isn’t from Alpharetta, but from East Gwinnett County, a largely Latino area outside Atlanta. Fire parents go to great lengths to get Jorge to games, arranging to meet him at gas stations around his home, landmarks they can find in his out-of-the-way neighborhood. Jorge is the best player on the team.”

The last year I played for Concorde, we had a Jorge – his name was Bruno - but it was the coach, not the parents, who went out of his way to ensure his presence at center midfield, which more often than not ensured a Concorde victory.

As my thoughts waft back and forth from southern memories to modern day models, I can’t decide if things have changed. Maybe they have; maybe it’s one of those ‘the more things change the more they stay the same’. The Fugees found some welcoming hands, but the under-reported racism of Clarkston works to bar the soccer team from better fields and keeps the team, its families, and coach at odds with ‘Old Clarkston’. In case you couldn’t connect the dots, ‘old’ means ‘white racists,’ which may or may not include the town’s mayor, Lee Swaney, who put on the same mask any small-town mayor does when Big Media comes muck-raking. The reporter left that part of the story largely untold, concentrating on wringing out his tear-jerking, heartfelt tale of kids whose “lives, after all, have been defined by bad calls.”

Sorry, but watching your father being gunned down, as at least one Fugee player had, is a bit more serious, don’tchathink, than a hand ball that isn’t called. St. John and his editor(s) had human interest gold and should have worked harder on the horrid sports-to-life metaphors - they had at least a few months to write this story looking at the timeline of the piece - and fleshing out the whole story, which no doubt means putting the entire town under the microscope as H. G. Bissinger did in his Friday Night Lights.

The story, without that side, is largely unfinished, further exhibited by the cut-and-run ending which seems to be the newspaper staple… but hey, Soccer is on the front page (with no mention of Beckham), so I’m not complaining.

————————————————————————————–
Update:

American Trifecta a first for EPL

Not much to say here except I love hearing two of my favorites - full disclosure we all share the same sponsor – making headlines in Europe. Dempsey started a movement that ended in a goal (and apparently did wind sprints after the game according to my man David Hirshey who was on the scene), while Gooch’s agent has admitted talks with both Chelsea and Olympique Lyon.

zlocke
on Jan 26th, 2007 - 11:23pm

Adam,
I have to admit that I found your blog post a bit judgemental for someone who doesn’t really know anything about Clarkston, GA.

First of all, Clarkston isn’t an hour away from any place that is considered to be part of Atlanta.

Secondly, don’t believe everything that you read.

All places have bad people in them. The problems in Clarkston aren’t primarily race related because most of the white people who lived here have already fled and the white people who remain are generally too liberal.

The problems in Clarkston are related to poverty and transients, mostly in the form of apartment dwellers whether refugee or not, shredding the tax base and making it difficult for the VERY small city of Clarkston to afford the public services that it needs to provide to the residents and refugees alike to make the town livable.

But the “story” I just told isn’t as interesting as the one that the NY Times writer was able to craft because it doesn’t have a bad guy and plucky little protagonists who’ve spent their entire lives climbing uphill or stereotypical Georgia rednecks, which I don’t know if I’ve EVER seen in Clarkston.

Finally, as a black man married to a jewish woman living across the street from a friendly old white couple, a young lesbian couple and mentoring a young somali boy, I think that you’re a bit off base in your blog post.

Regards,
z

Adam Spangler
on Jan 27th, 2007 - 10:33am

z-

thanks for taking the time to visit the site and write a comment. Some of the comments I made in the blog post you commented on are based on my own personal experience growing up in atlanta. furthermore, what you seem to be trying to say has more to do with the NYTimes article, not my writing. I would encourage you to take that up with the writer, Warren St. John, who is writing a book about the team (and they are making a movie). He’ll obviously be in and around Clarkston for the foreseeable future. My main point was that he alluded to a lot of racism without reporting any details. Hence, I called the piece under-reported. He should have found people like yourself and given everybody a better view of the situation. Why NY Times let that slide, i dont know. oh wait: they are going to make some movie money from it. does that explain it away?

good looking out
Adam

OBALEREKO AYOKU M
on Jul 4th, 2007 - 7:41am

Good day sir, i believe you are in good
state of mind.i am a striker in one of academy. club in NIGERIA Sir ,am really interested to be an international footballer but i don’t no the procedures to take,and i need football agent or manager that can be able to link me up with a club in Europe or America.
So,i think you should send me some informations to take from you.
I will be very glad to be one of your future and well
respected player.
How you can contact me on phone so,here is my number 2348054999851
or 014742008.
Email- ayinharmony@yahoo.com

THANKS.

from,
OBALEREKO AYOKU M

leave a comment items marked with * are required

Recent Comments

  • Adam: that’s a great idea Sean, and one that could give a club an edge in attracting young players who for...
  • Sean: You mentioned the value of education these college players get coming into a situation where they make low...
  • scar: what about Red Bull? Big stadium, smaller crowds than indoor. No one is comparing the two sports, but I’m...
  • A. Ruiz: “But for some reason it kind of blows my mind that professional indoor still exists. But looking at...
  • David Herrera: This is a great article, I’m pleased that my Club NASA as partnership with rush. Mr. Shulz is...